The application of coulomb active wedge theory and a calculated failure plane is favored by the. Rankine and euler formulas for metric steel columns. Maximum principal stress theory theories of elastic failure. For minimum active condition, rankine expressed the pressure at a point on the back of a retaining wall as p a k a v 2c k a. The rankine cycle was named after him and describes the performance of steam turbine systems, though the theoretical principle also applies to reciprocating engines such as steam locomotives. Coulombmohr theory or internal friction theory ift this theory is a modification of the maximum normal stress theory in the which the failure envelope is constructed by connecting the opposite corners of quadrants i and iii.
Later it was extended to include cohesive soil by bell in 1915. The rankine theory is favored by transportation professionals aashto, while the ncma prefers the coulomb approach. It commemorates william john macquorn rankine, professor of civil engineering at glasgow university, who was one of the first engineers in the uk to make a significant contribution to soil mechanics. In that sense, you could use both methods, and use the. According to the distortionenergy theory, the yield strength in shear is less than the yield strength in tension. Rankine theory the rankine theory is based on the assumption that the wall. The maximum distortion energy failure theory assumes failure by yielding in a more.
The stress states of soil elements a and b are called the rankine active state and the rankine passive state, respectively named after the first developer of this theory rankine, 1857. Orc power plants are often operated in cogenerating mode, i. Resal 1910 and bell 1915 extended rankines theory of earth pressure for cohesive soils. Theories of failure or yield criteria 1 maximum shearing stress theory 2 octahedral shearing stress theory 3 maximum normal stress theory for brittle materials. It assumes that the soil is cohesionless, the wall is frictionless, the soilwall interface is vertical, the failure surface on which the soil moves is planar, and the resultant force is angled parallel to the backfill. Maximum shearing stress theory or tresca criterion this theory says that.
Venants theory c maximum shear stress theory tresca theory d maximum strain energy theory beltramis theory 2. Maximum principal stress theory also known as rankines theory. Theories of failure maximum shear stress theory to use this theory for either two or threedimensional static stress in homogeneous, isotopic, ductile materials, first compute the three principal stresses 1, 2, 3 and the maximum shear stress as 12 max 2 max min 2 pp then compare the maximum shear stress to the failure criterion. Rankine gordon equation predictions of buckling loads by the euler formula is only reasonable for very long and slender struts that have very small geometrical imperfections. It should be emphasized that, depending on the backfill sloping angle, the active and passive thrusts cal culated with these methods could be quite different. Alagha foundation engineering retaining walls we will use rankine theory to discusses the stability of these types of failures. Aug 29, 2019 maximum principal stress theory rankine theory if one of the principal stresses. These topicwise notes are useful for the preparation of various upcoming exams like gate civil engineeringce ies barc sscje state engineering services examinations and other important upcoming competitive. There is no adhesion or friction between the wall and soil lateral pressure is limited to vertical walls failure in the backfill occurs as a sliding wedge along an assumed failure plane defined by. Each of these rankine states is associated with a family of failure planes. Rankine s theory maximumnormal stress theory, developed in 1857 by william john macquorn rankine, is a stress field solution that predicts active and passive earth pressure. As originally proposed, rankines theory is applied to uniform cohesionless soil only. The following cases of active earth pressure on cohesionless backfill will now be considered. Rankine earth pressure theory coulomb earth pressure theory the rankine theory assumes.
Resal 1910 and bell 1915 extended rankine s theory of earth pressure for cohesive soils. The mohr theory of failure, also known as the coulombmohr criterion or internalfriction theory, is based on the famous mohrs circle. Such theories aim to predict, from the behaviors of materials in a simple tensile test, when elastic. Introduction to structural mechanics lothar wolf, mujid s. Maximum principal stress theory theories of elastic. The angle of the failure plane with the horizontal. He was a founding contributor, with rudolf clausius and william thomson lord kelvin, to the science of thermodynamics, particularly focusing on the first of the three thermodynamic laws. In other words, the interface between the soil and the retaining wall is not assumed frictionless as it is in rank. Maximum principal stress theory video lecture from theories of elastic failure chapter of strength of materials subject for all engineering students. Organic rankine cycle an overview sciencedirect topics. Pdf rankines earth pressure theory for nonlinear failure. There are two wellknown classical earth pressure theories.
The theory is based on the assumption that inelastic behavior or failure is governed by a specified maximum normal strain. In rankine theory the graph is always square irrespective of the values of sigma, in 2 dimension. Our chosen failure theory needs to be appropriate to the type of failure that will occur for example we couldnt apply the same failure theory to glass and aluminum. Coulomb theory considers wall friction and angle of slope, both are included in the equations for earth pressure constant k, the resultant force is making an angle, equal to the friction of the wall, from the plane normal to wall. Rankines earth pressure theory for nonlinear failure envelopes conference paper pdf available january 2007 with 768 reads how we measure reads. It assumes that the soil is cohesionless, the wall is frictionless, the soilwall interface is vertical, the failure surface on which the soil moves is planar, and the. The theory is based on a limiting energy of distortion, i. Maximum principal stress theory also known as rankine s theory 2. Pdf it is about an introduction to failure theories find, read and cite all the research you. Yielding occurs when the maximum shear stress in the material.
In this paper the onedimensional theory is put on a firmer footing. The organic rankine cycle orc is a rankine process, where the working fluid is an organic fluid instead of water, which is used in conventional steam power plants. Jan 04, 2019 the primary difference between rankine and coulomb earth pressure theories is that coulombs considers a frictional retaining wall. Pure shear intersect the pure shear load line with the failure line to determine the shear strength since failure line is a function of tensile and compressive strengths, shear strength is also a function of these terms. Basic earth pressure theory youll recall from your college soil mechanics classes the coulomb 1776 and rankine 1857 theories of active earth pressure. A large numbers of different theories have been formulated. Failure surface according to maximum principal stress theory this theory of yielding has very poor agreement with experiment. Each furnishes expressions for active and passive pressures for a soil mass at the state of failure. But, predicating the failure stresses for members subjected to biaxial or triaxial stresses is much more complicated. Elements of retaining walls each retaining wall divided into three parts. The principal theories of failure for a member subjected to biaxial stress are as follows.
Rankine theory does not include wall friction, for sloping backfill, the resultant is parallel to the slope. That being said, it is typically considered that rankine underpredicts the true orientation of the failure surface, whereas coulomb overpredicts the orientation. In general, the rankine cycle is an idealized thermodynamic cycle of a constant pressure heat engine that converts part of heat into mechanical work. Most of the students attempting this question for first time will give rectangle as answer but square is. Another popular method to estimate the earth pressure is the logarithmicspiral method proposed by terzaghi 1943. Thermodynamic theory of nonideal detonation and failure w byers brown. Since the theory was only sketched out graphically in the previous publication, the first. As originally proposed, rankine s theory is applied to uniform cohesionless soil only.
Optimize a design comparing different failure theories. Rankines assumptions for earth pressure theory for active. Strength of materials and failure theories 2010 state of stress this is a 2d state of stress only the independent stress components are named. Dry or moist backfill submerged backfill partly submerged backfill backfill with uniform surcharge backfill with sloping surcharge. Various theory of failure maximum principal stress theory rankines theory maximum principal strain theory st. Rankines theory specifies calculation of earth pressure based on mohrcoulomb criterion which assumes a linear failure envelope in mohrs stress space.
In other words, the interface between the soil and the retaining wall is not assumed frictionless as it is in rankine theory. In soil mechanics, what is the essential difference between. Maximum principalnormal stress theory rankines theory. A single stress component z can exist on the zaxis and the state of stress is still called 2d and the following equations apply. Mohrs theory is often used in predicting the failure of brittle materials, and is applied to cases of 2d stress. Maximum principal stress theory also known as rankines theory 2. For the rankine active state, the failure planes are oriented at. The rankine formula is a more general formula and can be used for both the long as well as the short column. Mae 322 machine design lecture 3 mercer university. The rankine lecture is widely viewed as the most prestigious of the invited lectures in geotechnics. Earth pressure and retaining wall basics for nongeotechnical. The greatest principal stress theory rankine this simply states that in a complex stress situation, the material fails when the greatest principal stress equals the maximum allowable value. Failure theories study notes for mechanical engineering. The active earth pressure at any depth h below the surface of the backfill, as per rankines theory, is given by p p k p.
In practice, however, most column struts suffer plastic knockdown and the experimentally obtained buckling loads are much less than the euler predictions. Through the champion study plan for gate civil engineeringce, we are providing the very useful basic notes and other important resources on every topic of each subject. Maximum shear stress theory tresca, guest, coulomb applied satisfactorily to ductile materials, the theory is based on the concept of limiting shearing stress at which failure occurs. Rankine versus coulomb earth pressures earth retention. Used to describe fracture of brittle materials such as cast iron limitations o doesnt distinguish between tension or compression. For and, what is the physical boundary for rankine failure theory. Theories of failure a rankine or maximum principal stress theory b saint venant or maximum principal strain theory c tresca or maximum shear stress. Apr 30, 2014 various theory of failure maximum principal stress theory rankines theory maximum principal strain theory st.
The primary difference between rankine and coulomb earth pressure theories is that coulombs considers a frictional retaining wall. Rankines active earth pressure for cohesive backfill. Aug 05, 2016 maximum principal stress theory video lecture from theories of elastic failure chapter of strength of materials subject for all engineering students. Application of lateral earth pressure theories to design rankine theory. Rankine theory rankine 1857 developed the simplest procedure for computing the minimum active and maximum passive earth pressure. Rankine s active earth pressure for cohesive backfill. In soil mechanics, what is the essential difference. Theories of failures study notes for civil engineering. However, the theory has been used successfully for brittle materials.
1417 979 1188 451 627 205 53 94 213 1457 437 943 1393 793 798 93 615 1122 165 512 1273 216 430 432 887 815 1237 929 1219 877 30 1043 1063 910